Litigation

Protect and serve — themselves

Nine civil lawsuits. Thirteen years. A sample of what the Lake Stevens Police Department is capable of when accountability fails.

Documented settlements total more than a million dollars. The actual figure is likely far higher: Warbis, Brunner/Thor, and Heisler were resolved on confidential terms; other complaints were settled as grievances before a lawsuit was ever filed; and still more were resolved privately without becoming public.

2025FILED 2025 · SAC FILED JUNE 1, 2026 BY PHAROS LAW PLLC · 2:25-CV-01111-BJRPENDING

Bloom v. City of Lake Stevens et al.

§ 1983, § 1985 civil conspiracy, defamation, malicious prosecution, first amendment retaliation

The Complaint alleges that the Lake Stevens Police Department engaged in a pattern of misconduct in which the officers not only failed to investigate credible reports of domestic and sexual violence but actively worked to discredit and silence Plaintiff and her children. It pleads violations of the First, Fourth, Fifth, and Fourteenth Amendments under 42 U.S.C. § 1983, civil conspiracy under § 1985, and Washington state claims for defamation (slander) and malicious prosecution.

The Monell claim frames the conduct as the predictable product of longstanding City customs: disbelieving female DV and sexual-assault victims, race- and bias-based policing against people of color and immigrants, retaliating against complainants, and burying internal-affairs complaints by deleting, downgrading, or reclassifying them while altering underlying police reports.

The Complaint further alleges that LSPD altered historical police reports to sanitize a repeat offender's record as new victims came forward. It claims Plaintiff Bloom's race was changed from "Multiracial" to "White"; the twice-arrested, twice-fingerprinted, and twice-jailed suspect was changed from "White" to "Unknown"; domestic-violence referrals were removed; and historical residential addresses and phone numbers were altered. These changes, the Complaint argues, are part of the same custom of altering records to protect favored subjects and undermine complainants.

Named defendants: City of Lake Stevens; Detective Kristen Parnell; Deputy Chief Jeff Young; Chief Jeffrey G. Beazizo; Officer Judah Marshall; John Does 1–10.

2025Filed Mar 10, 2025 · 2:25-cv-00426-BJRPENDING

Bennett v. State of Washington & City of Lake Stevens

§ 1983 excessive force, ADA/WLAD, failure to train and supervise

Active federal case about a young man who was shot and killed. Officer Kerry Bernhard is alleged to have left her patrol vehicle unlocked, running, and with the keys inside; when James Blancocotto — an unarmed young man with observable mental health and substance issues — entered the vehicle, Bernhard attacked and shot him at close distance. He died January 13, 2023. The 2011 Rufener Assessment commissioned by the City had named Bernhard specifically as a "liability" whose behavior was "unsafe" and who "spins people up for no reason" — twelve years of written notice before Blancocotto's death.

2019Filed Oct 24, 2019 · Settled May 2021 · Amount undisclosedSETTLED

Heisler v. City of Lake Stevens

Wrongful death of a suicidal veteran

Officer Alexis Warbis and then-Corporal Kristen Parnell waited in their patrol cars at the bottom of the driveway after the spouse instructed them by phone to enter immediately. They did not knock, did not check the garage, and ultimately had Mrs. Heisler enter first; she found her husband hanging from the rafters. Both officers were retained after settlement.

2015Filed Nov 2015 · 9th Cir. mediation · Amount undisclosedSETTLED

Brunner / Thor v. City of Lake Stevens

§ 1983 — law-enforcement database misuse, failure to audit

Action alleging Officer Thor used law enforcement databases 45+ times to cyberstalk a private woman. Plaintiffs alleged the City had no monitoring or auditing system in place to detect database abuse, despite a history of prior lawsuits involving LSPD officers and protected databases. The Complaint describes a pattern in which the City ignored warning signs of database misuse and failed to implement safeguards, effectively allowing officers to manipulate and access sensitive records for personal purposes. Settled in Ninth Circuit mediation.

2015FILED OCT 2015 · SETTLED JAN 2018 · $400,,000SETTLED

Taylor v. City of Lake Stevens

Retaliation, wrongful discharge, and defamation

Officer Dennis Taylor was forced out for supporting Sgt. Jamison's sexual harassment and discrimination lawsuit. Then-City Administrator Jan Berg notified Taylor on or about August 6, 2015 that she was recommending discharge and issuance of a Brady letter under Lexipol Policy #606 — a career-ending credibility-destruction mechanism. The Brady-letter tactic parallels the "false reporter" label LSPD later relayed about Plaintiff Bloom to other agencies.

2014Filed ~2014 · Amount undisclosedSETTLED

Warbis v. City of Lake Stevens

Defamation and failure-to-defend by Officer Steve Warbis

Defamation and failure-to-defend action brought by Officer Warbis after the City publicly described his earlier conduct as "indefensible." Warbis's November 12, 2014 deposition is a primary source on LSPD culture — including Chief Celori's instruction to drop the grievance ("it's just a little letter in your file… I will have the thing removed by the end of the year") and confirmation that Jim Barnes served as Guild President at Loudermill hearings while simultaneously investigating OPS complaints.

2013Filed Nov 4, 2013 · Settled Jul 2014 · $325,000SETTLED

Jamison v. City of Lake Stevens

Sex discrimination, hostile work environment, retaliation

Sgt. Julie Jamison — 17-year LSPD employee — reported sexual harassment by Detective Lambier. Chief Celori conducted the investigation in-house and found it "not sustained," then directed Jamison to work from home while Lambier worked normally. Retaliation followed: schedule changes, surprise audits, demotion to graveyard patrol. Mayor Vern Little and City Administrator Jan Berg are quoted directing the department: "No more personnel problems, no more complaints."

2013Filed Sep 4, 2013 · Snohomish County 13-2-07220-1UNKNOWN

Moreno-Toro v. City of Lake Stevens

42 U.S.C. § 1983 — warrantless search of a Latina homeowner's residence

Detective Wachtveitl, Sgt. Brooks, Officer Warbis, and Detective Thomas allegedly directed a private citizen, Douglas Montzingo, to first enter Plaintiff Janet Moreno-Toro’s residence and search it for approximately 30 minutes before police arrived. The officers then barged through the front door of her home of 14 years, forced Mrs. Moreno and her sick nearly one-year-old baby out of the house, and searched every room for 3–4 hours — including bedrooms, bathrooms, drawers, closets, kitchen, living room, dining room, and the attached garage — while photographing her belongings. A warrant was obtained only after the initial unlawful entry and search had already occurred. Mrs. Moreno, who has no criminal record, called 911 during the incident to report that she was being harassed by police and that officers were searching her residence without a warrant.

2012Filed ~2012 · Settled ~2013SETTLED

Fenter v. City of Lake Stevens

Civil rights — warrantless vehicle stop · Settled $100,000

Civil rights claim arising from a warrantless vehicle stop by Officers Steve Warbis and James Wellington under Sgt. Ron Brooks. Settled for $100,000; the underlying conduct was later described publicly as "indefensible." 

Complaint not publicly archived on this site.